Showing posts with label Derby. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Derby. Show all posts

12 January 2020

Derbyshire Bridges: 1. Cathedral Green Footbridge


As with my last post, the title of this post is not an indication to expect lots of posts about bridges in Derbyshire, it's just a placeholder for the future. If you have suggestions of interesting bridges to visit in Derbyshire, let me know via the comments.

Derby's Cathedral Green footbridge was opened in 2009, following a design competition held in 2007. The design, by Whitbybird (team members now dispersed into Move Architecture and Ramboll), was for a moveable cable-stayed pedestrian bridge. Mechanical engineering design was undertaken by M G Bennett and Associates Ltd (team members now in Eadon Consulting).

Spanning the River Derwent, the bridge is around 57m long with a 22m tall central mast. As well as creating a new river crossing, the intention was to contribute to revitalising the Cathedral Green open space.

The bridge deck is cranked in plan, with an 19m back-span and 38m main-span, supported by stays from a tilted mast. The back span crosses a historic mill race. The reason the bridge is moveable is not for navigation, but to allow the bridge to be moved clear of the main river in times of flood.

In this arrangement, the layout is intended to allow pedestrians to continue to use both riverside walkways, an arrangement that is best understood either from the aerial view on Google Maps, or from this video:


The ability to retain the riverside walkway in an open position seems slightly unnecessary, as the mill race is covered over and hardly an obstacle any more. When I visited, the riverside path was also closed in both directions for construction work.

The asymmetry of the bridge led to the mechanical engineering being relatively unusual. The bridge rotates about a central pintle bearing, but its main supports are a wheel under the central area, and a second wheel at the rear of the back-span, which resists uplift and runs in a curved track. A hydraulic motor drives a pinion against a rack at the rear of the back-span when the bridge is required to rotate.

A further pair of wheel-bearings lock the other-end of the main span in place, the load in these being highly dependent on the thermal state of the bridge. It's interesting to think while crossing the bridge that it is so carefully balanced on just a few individual wheels.

The site looked so neglected and overgrown when I visited that I doubted the bridge still opened, but it seems that it does. Indeed, the impression of neglect was considerable, as will be obvious from some of my photos. The benefits of a stainless steel parapet are clear, although the mesh infill has been severely dented in several places, and adorned with love-locks.

So many "designer" bridges of the millennium years share the same conditions of grime and disrepair now. It was easier for aspirational local government bodies to secure capital funding for ambitious new infrastructure than to provide the funding for their proper maintenance.

This bridge is a case in point. I visited on a grey, overcast day at a time when the city centre was largely devoid of activity. It took a feat of imagination to see how this bridge may have looked soon after opening, well-used and glowing in the sunshine.

The bridge design is impressive and well-considered (there's a technical paper referenced below which is well worth reading if you can get hold of it), but on the day I visited it felt very much like seeing an expensive sports car covered in dust and with insulting messages finger-painted in the dirt.

Further information:

12 June 2009

Bridges dominate Prime Minister's Award shortlist

Every year, the British Prime Minister gives an award for "Better Public Building", intended to recognise not just architectural or engineering excellence, but also good procurement, positive community impact and sustainability. Of the 24 entries shortlisted this year, five are bridges, and two others have bridges as a key part of the scheme.

As this award bucks the trends of the other engineering and architectural awards schemes, it's worth seeing which five bridges have been shortlisted. They're certainly not all the usual suspects (none of the four bridges recently featured in RIBA's awards are here, for example, although one (Castleford) was shortlisted last year). Bridges often make a good showing in the Better Public Building scheme, but this looks like a vintage year.

Cathedral Green, Derby
Designed by Ramboll (formerly Whitbybird), this is a cable-stayed swing footbridge (yet to be officially named) spanning over both the River Derwent and an adjacent mill race. It swings to one side when the main river floods. It's nice to see a cable-stay bridge with so few cables, also one that is modest and simple rather than unduly flamboyant. It has been shortlisted, apparently, because "the ingenious bridge design allows rotation using minimal energy" (inherent in the swing bridge choice). No mention is made of the fact that it opened a year behind plan and well over budget.

This one was chosen for its "construction innovation and streamlined engineering" rather than architectural flair, although the design (by Scott Wilson, Benaim and Yee Associates) is admirably done. Launched incrementally, it bypasses the existing Kincardine Bridge. Each pier is supported on a single monopile, somewhat harking back to the good old days where bridges sat on hand-dug caisson foundations. Nice to see engineering get its proper recognition.

Infinity Bridge, Stockton-on-Tees
I've covered Expedition Engineering's footbridge here extensively before, so there's not much new to say other than that I laughed at the awards website's statement that it comprises "two steel arches supporting a pre-cast concrete deck produce one of the country’s longest footbridges but – at 125mm – one of the thinnest walking surfaces." Of course, it's only 125mm thick spanning transversely, with deeper edge beams spanning longitudinally - and thinner walking surfaces exist on many steel bridge decks.

Lewisburn, Kielder
Designed by Forestry Civil Engineering, an arm of the Forestry Commission, this footbridge in the Kielder Forest must be the real wild card of the five bridges up for an award. They're no strangers to prizewinning bridges, with a BCIA award for the Salcey Forest Walkway [PDF]. It's a fairly attractive low-cost cable-stay structure, although the timber deck is somewhat let down by the fairly clumsy pylons.
I've covered this footbridge before as well, having visited it earlier this year. The design by Buro Happold is one that I find problematic. The awards people seem to like its "elegance", finding it "visually striking" and with "high quality workmanship". I'd agree except about the elegance - the structural form is awkward and also far from economic. Having said that the fabrication of a complex structure like this is undeniably an impressive achievement.

19 December 2008

Bridges news roundup

Derby, swing footbridge, delayed, over budget
£3.8m design now £4.3m, 11 months late, not yet open (pictured below, click image for larger version)


Calatrava knock-off at Achill Sound now open
€5m swing highway bridge opens 7 months late, and looks a little odd too (best photo I can find online is on flickr, showing what looks like a steel arch bridge with curved hangers) Update 6th January 2009: better photo now available

Genuine Calatrava opens in Valencia
€35m Serreria Bridge opens, 11% over budget, designers everywhere murmur in surprise at the sight of an iconic cable-stayed bridge which actually uses back-stays, lots of photos here

Bridge opens on time, on budget
No link for that one, couldn't find an appropriate story!